What Happens If The Sale Of A Home Falls Through Due To Title Issues?

The excitement of buying or selling a house is meant to be contagious. It’s a chance for buyers to move into a home that they feel like is theirs. Sellers are relieved to be able to move forward and possibly unlock money that was locked up in the property. Sometimes, however, the whole process can come to a grinding stop, not because the buyer has backed out, or because financing has collapsed, but due to something less expected, such as title issues. Bonardi & Uzdavinis has seen many real estate transactions fall through at the last moment because of hidden problems in a property’s past. Most people do not think about title issues until they are at the closing table or, even more frustrating, when they find out they cannot get to that point because of a problem. What happens when a deal falls through because of title issues? Is it the end of a deal?

Feel Free To Schedule A Consultation

Contact Bonardi & Uzdavinis without delay to arrange a FREE consultation.

LET’S TALK

What do we mean by “title issues”?

Titles are the proof that a person owns property. It should be easy to understand and transferable. In the real world titles can get messy. They can carry old baggage, such as liens for unpaid debts or errors in recording documents. Common examples include:

• Outstanding Liens — maybe the property taxes were not paid by the previous owner or contractors who weren’t paid.
• Errors on public records– A typo or missing signature can cause more problems than you think.
• Boundary disputes — When neighbors disagree about property lines, title can be clouded.
• Unreleased Mortgages — an old loan which appears in records as though it is still active.
• Claims Of Ownership– Heirs, ex-spouses or business partners that never signed off on the document can suddenly appear.

These can all raise red flags when a title search is conducted. If those red flags are not resolved, then the sale will not proceed.

What are the most common ways to discover title issues?

These problems are not usually discovered by the buyer. Title searches are done for this purpose. A title company or lawyer will dig into public records before a closing to verify ownership and check for issues. This process does not begin at the beginning. Both the buyer and the seller may be weeks into their planning, organizing movers and dreaming of what comes next when they receive the call “There’s an issue with the title.” The timing of everything can be even more disruptive.

What happens if the sale falls through?

A failed sale because of title issues can be devastating for buyers. The buyer has probably already invested time, emotion, and money – home inspections, appraisals or even loan approvals. Most contracts will protect you from losing your entire purchase if there is a problem with the title. When a defect in the title makes it impossible to close, earnest money deposits will usually be refunded. There’s also the emotional cost. Imagine buying the “perfect” house, only to find out that an old lien is blocking the sale. Others walk away, preferring to not gamble on an uncertain timeline. Some buyers walk away completely, not wanting to risk their money on an uncertain timeline.

What about sellers?

The situation can be frustrating for sellers. They may not even be aware of a title issue until the deal has been finalized. The sale that they had been counting on to fund their next purchase, or even for financial planning, is now stuck. Fixing the problem can be fast or painfully slow, depending on what’s wrong. It might take only a few paperwork weeks to clear a mortgage that has been paid off but not released. A contested ownership claim can take months or even years to resolve, and may involve court. The seller may lose buyers who are impatient and don’t wish to wait.

Legal Implications for a Title-Related Collapse

This is where things get more technical. The legal consequences of a failed sale due to title issues depend on the contract of purchase and the nature of problem.

• The seller must usually deliver a title that is free from defects if the contract stipulated “marketable title”. If the seller fails to comply, the buyer can cancel the contract with no penalty.
• The buyer could sue the seller for damages if they misrepresented their title, for example claiming that they owned it when they did not.
• If the issue is a resolvable one, sometimes both parties will agree to extend deadlines until the problem is resolved.

Attorneys are often called in to help, as “title defect” can be a very broad term. Some defects are merely technical; others can make ownership uncertain.

Title insurance: the safety net that isn’t always perfect

In these conversations, you’ll hear a lot about title insurance. Title insurance protects the buyer (and their lender) against financial loss in case a hidden problem arises after the sale. Here’s the problem: title insurance does not always stop a deal falling through. This is not a magical eraser. The policy will not be issued if the defect is found before the closing date. This means that the sale will be halted until the problem is resolved. Title insurance is important but it doesn’t come for free.

Feel Free To Schedule A Consultation

Contact Bonardi & Uzdavinis without delay to arrange a FREE consultation.

LET’S TALK

Can the deal be saved?

Not all title issues are fatal to a sale. Many can be corrected, but it takes persistence, time and in some cases, legal action.

• Liens are often paid at closing by deducting funds from the proceeds of the sale.
• Correcting clerical errors is possible with updated files.
• boundary disputes can be resolved by agreements or surveys.
• Heir Claims can require probate court. This may take more time, but it is still possible to solve.

It is a question of whether the buyer will wait. Some buyers will wait, especially if it is a unique property. Some simply leave the property to avoid any uncertainty.

Common Mistakes Sellers Make

Many title issues would have been detected earlier by sellers who did their homework. Title searches before listing are not common, but can save you time and embarrassment. Sellers assume that everything is fine until it’s not. Perhaps an old lien was not cleared. Perhaps a divorce decree was not filed correctly. This is the kind of “silent problem” that can ruin a deal right when everyone’s about to celebrate.

Title problems: emotional realities behind them

It’s easy for people to treat liens and other documents as abstract. Behind them is often real tension. Families may be involved in disputes or arguments between buyers and sellers, turning what was supposed to be a simple transaction into a personal one. Families have delayed moving, children started new schools late and retirement plans were put on hold because of a paperwork snag. Title issues can have a huge impact on people’s lives. That’s why it is so important to resolve them as quickly as possible.

What Attorneys Can Do in These Situations

When a deal falls through, attorneys play two major roles:

1. Problem solving. They determine the cause of the title issue, and then chart the quickest path to resolution, whether it is negotiating with lienholders or filing corrective documentation, or even going to court, if needed.
2. Protecting customers. They make sure that buyers do not lose deposits unfairly and sellers are not liable for unexpected liabilities. They can also handle extensions and renegotiations to salvage some deals.

At Bonardi & Uzdavinis we focus on clarity. We explain to our clients the real issues, their options, and whether it’s worth waiting.

How to prevent title issues from ruining a sale

There are ways to reduce risk, even if not all problems can be prevented.

• Before listing a property, sellers should conduct a title search. This is not standard but it can be very valuable.
• Buyers need to carefully read contracts. Be sure that they contain protections in the event of a title not being marketable.
• It is important that both parties communicate. Deals can fail because of a lack of communication.

Final Thoughts

It’s not just about the paperwork when a sale of a house falls through because of title issues. Everyone involved is affected by disappointment, stress and disruption. It doesn’t have to be the final chapter. Many of these issues can be resolved or at least managed with less risk if you have the right legal advice. We have seen first-hand how difficult it can be to deal with title issues, particularly when they occur at the last minute. We’ve seen that preparation, patience and legal expertise are essential to keeping deals alive or, at least, protecting clients from unnecessary losses. If you find yourself facing a “clouded” title, remember that it is not always a deal breaker. Even if you do, the right lawyer will ensure that you are protected and ready to move on to the next opportunity.

Feel Free To Schedule A Consultation

Contact Bonardi & Uzdavinis without delay to arrange a FREE consultation.

LET’S TALK