When Can You Sue For Emotional Distress?

While emotional distress is intangible, it can be as damaging and disruptive to a person’s daily life as a physical injury. As in other states, Florida allows individuals who have been emotionally harmed by the negligence or intent of another to sue for compensation. This article explains how and when you can sue in Florida for emotional distress, focusing on the key legal concepts that will strengthen your case.

Feel Free To Schedule A Consultation

Contact Bonardi & Uzdavinis without delay to arrange a FREE consultation.

LET’S TALK

What is emotional distress?

Emotional distress is mental suffering or anguish that’s caused by the actions of another party. This is often referred to as a “non-economic injury”, meaning that it does not result in a direct financial loss, but instead affects mental and emotional health. Emotional distress can include:

• Anxiety
• The following are some of the ways to reduce your risk:
• Insomnia
• Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
• Loss of enjoyment in life

Florida law recognizes that emotional distress is a legitimate injury, for which damages can be awarded. However, the conditions under which claims may be allowed will vary depending on the particulars of each case.

Emotional distress and physical harm

In the past, emotional distress claims have been tied to physical injury. If someone suffered a broken foot in an accident that was caused by negligence on the part of another, they can sue for both the physical as well as the emotional pain. It was more difficult to claim emotional distress when there wasn’t a physical injury. Florida has, along with many other states in the country, evolved its position on emotional distress claims. In some cases, plaintiffs may be able to sue even if there is no physical injury. It is especially true of conditions such as PTSD or depression, which can arise even without physical injury.

There are different types of emotional distress claims

Negligent Infliction Emotional Stress (NIED)

Florida law allows a plaintiff to file a claim if:

1. The defendant was negligent.
2. The plaintiff suffered significant emotional distress as a result of the negligence.
3. The emotional distress was manifested physically (e.g., tremors or hives) or under certain circumstances.

Florida courts require that there be a link between emotional distress and physical symptoms or proximity of a traumatic event, also known as the “zone of danger rule”.

Intentional Infliction Of Emotional Distress

Florida recognizes intentional infliction claims. A plaintiff must establish the following to win such a case:

1. The defendant’s behavior was extreme and outrageous.
2. It is not clear whether the conduct was deliberate or reckless.
3. The plaintiff suffered severe emotional distress as a result of the conduct.

Extreme and outrageous behaviour is judged according to a high standard. It’s often described as behavior which exceeds the bounds of civilized behavior. Examples of extreme behavior include public humiliation or harassment, threats of violence and other forms.

Bystander claims and the Zone of Danger Rule

Bystanders in Florida who witness a traumatic incident may sue if they suffer emotional distress. If a parent sees their child injured or killed by another person’s negligence, then they can file a claim, as long as they are close enough to feel the trauma. This is in line with Florida’s zone of danger rule.

Florida’s Emotional Distress Test

Evidence is needed to prove emotional distress and the impact it has on the plaintiff. These are the most common forms of evidence used in emotional distress claims.

1. Direct Testimony – The plaintiff’s detailed description of the emotional pain they have experienced, and how this has affected them in their daily lives and their mental health.
2. Expert Testimony. Mental health professionals such as psychiatrists and psychologists can provide expert opinions or evaluations to support claims of emotional distress.
3. Medical Records: Documentation of diagnosis, treatment, or medication that supports the plaintiff’s claim of emotional or mental harm.
4. Witness Testimony: Statements by family members, friends or co-workers who can attest that the plaintiff has changed in behavior or emotion.

Feel Free To Schedule A Consultation

Contact Bonardi & Uzdavinis without delay to arrange a FREE consultation.

LET’S TALK

Common mistakes to avoid

The following mistakes can compromise a claim for emotional distress:

1. Failure to Document Emotional Harm: Proving emotional harm is difficult without thorough documentation or expert witness testimony.
2. Delaying legal action: Florida has a four-year statute of limitations for emotional distress cases based on negligence.
3. Neglecting Beneficiaries Update: If emotional distress is claimed in relation to estate or probate matters, it’s critical to ensure proper legal documentation.

Emotional distress in specific scenarios

Birth Injury Cases

Florida courts are increasingly recognizing emotional distress claims, especially in cases of birth injuries. A mother who has a difficult delivery that results in permanent injury to her child can claim emotional distress.

Workplace Harassment

Employment disputes that involve harassment or wrongful dismissal often lead to claims of intentional infliction. Florida courts have awarded compensation in cases involving extreme and outrageous conduct by employers or coworkers.

Settlement Amounts & Jury Verdicts

Compensation for emotional distress can vary widely depending on severity and circumstances. There is no cap in Florida on the non-economic damages that can be claimed for emotional distress, but there may be limits if medical malpractice claims are involved. Compensation includes:

• Medical expenses for therapy and counseling
• Loss of earnings or reduced earning capacity
• Damages for pain and suffering that are not economic

How to strengthen your claim

1. Seek Treatment Immediately: Consult a mental health specialist immediately to document your situation.
2. Gather Evidence: Record incidents, symptoms and their impact on you daily.
3. Legal Representation – An experienced attorney will help you navigate Florida laws and make a compelling argument.

Florida Specific Considerations

Florida’s emotional distress claims have specific legal implications, including:

• Florida has a rule of comparative negligence, which can reduce the compensation awarded if a plaintiff is found to be partially responsible.
• Community Standards: What is considered “extreme” and “outrageous” behavior can vary depending on the local norms and social expectations.

In order to successfully sue for emotional distress, you must be well-prepared and have a good understanding of the state’s laws. Plaintiffs need to present convincing evidence to prove the extent of their emotional distress, regardless if the claim is based on negligent or intentional acts. You can improve your chances of receiving fair compensation by consulting with a qualified lawyer and assembling strong evidence. Take the steps necessary to protect yourself and seek justice if you feel you have suffered emotional distress as a result of someone else’s action.